Lets face it, if you want to get a full Red Samurai set with all the extras it's quite expensive. Being able to get this and the other made to order sets with the extras is just a steal for these caps. I already had the set on a 65% but added this TKL set last month, love it!
I heard GMK keycaps were the best quality, but the price always put me off. I took the plunge and bought these with my last membership discount. I received them right before the Give Me Keys sale. I was completely blown away by these keycaps so much that I ended up buying two more sets. I get it now..
First, let me say something good: I've never in my life held a keycap that felt anywhere near as good as these do. The texture is great, and my camera did a decent job of capturing it in the 2nd picture (on the enter key above the shift key pictured).
Now then, onto my very specific and situational gripe:
The poor top layer design means that by the time it gets the UPS treatment it's only good for keeping the caps inside the box. Nothing was damaged or anything, but to me, it really does ruin the experience of buying an (at the time of purchase) $80 keycap set when you open it to see that nothing's stayed organized. Note that I bought the TKL set, and they utilize the top layer only for the keys in this set. I didn't really care to check, but if the bottom layer could be used, that might solve this issue pretty easily. It's not that fact that I needed to take a couple minutes to organize it, it's that they're obviously meant to stay in place and this packaging didn't achieve that during shipment. I took the picture after putting about half of the jumbled ones back, but it was even worse than that. Pretty much nothing stays in place in this packaging.
Also, one of the shift keys has bit of hard plastic that I think I might just try to gently file off. Not a huge deal, but again, something that I wouldn't expect when paying a fair premium for a product.
All in all, they ARE gorgeous, they ARE quality, but it felt like the ball was ran 90 yards here. Stuff like this might not matter to a lot of people, but it matters to me.
I am unaware if other sets besides the TKL set will be affected, but I'm assuming they make these universal so that they can use them for all 3 sets. YMMV if you purchase one of the other sets.