I recently purchased these keycaps along with the elvish set, and my reviews are about the same of all the LoR keycap sets. The packaging leaves much to be desired. Their all just set up in rows, and it's hard to tell which keycaps go in which row or to tell from a glace that you have all the keycaps, they just seem kind of thrown in there, for as much detail as they put into the outside of the box and the keycaps themselves, you'd think they would be better organized especially when other $30-$60 sets are individually spaced out in their packaging. That said, they keycaps themselves are great. I'm not a massive fan of the MT3 profile, but I'm willing to put up with it for the novelty. I just probably won't be using them 100% of the time.
Great look, great feel, perfect for LOTR fans and keyboard enthusiasts
These keycaps are pretty much perfect. I love the MT3 profile and the PBT has a very light, subtle texture that makes them feel great under finger. The Durin's Forge accents are a must in my opinion. The orange is a perfect contrast to the grey and off-white of the base set. I can't recommend these enough!