I hoped it to be better than them but the feel and sound is too similar to recommend one against the other. yes, these switches are a bit more tactile but not in a big way ( and a bit louder? I didn't put them in the same case so... IDK ) and probably cheaper and obtainium
While I haven't tried these exact switches, I have tried the Midnight Pros that they're based on - as silent switches, they are some of my favorites, on-par with TTC's higher-end offerings. Not the most quiet, but the sound they do make is both inoffensive and satisfying - and I think they feel great. However...A general note about all the recent Kailh switches with stems that look like these; mostly but not all silent switches - those stems can and will stress some keycaps. They aren't quite as bad as the first run of BOX switches, but I still recommend caution with these. Fret not, though - there's a tool available for getting those stems back into safe spec: https://geon.works/products/geon-trimmer
@HoffmanMyster - I think I mentioned a tool like this a while back; at the time only prototype versions of a bladed tool were floating around - but Geon's take on it is basically exactly what I was getting at - just a hard metal version of a cap mount to force too-big stems into shape. I'd love to see more competition in that space *hint hint*
tonsoffun49The stress cracks are the white areas at the corners, at either end of the horizontal part of the + shape. Here are some other angles, and more up-close:
search
search
In the photo above they're the squiggly white marks on the left side of the +, visible more as highlighted edges on the right side.
For comparison, an undamaged one:
search
Compare the above photo with the first of the previous pair; no white edges on either side of the + on these fresh caps, and hardly any on caps mounted on in-spec Cherry switches.
Tempted to try except for the 35g total force, which seems a bit too light for me personally and only 1 option of 35pcs. Just a tad too little as well.
has IDOBAO sent these to anyone for review? I get that they’re a new switch but there’s no information out there aside from their store page. I'm always interested in trying different silenced switches but without any real info on these and with 9 days left to commit, I'm gonna have to sit this one out.
frankpassalacquaSame, force curve please. I get it is a light switch but on the tactile one, is there barely a bump? P shaped? d shaped? D shaped? What are we looking at here?
frankpassalacqua@frankpassalacqua Hello! I am leaving the force curve graphs below for the Elf Mechanical Switches. The sound tests will be uploaded sometime this week.
Purple: