Showing 1 of 201 conversations about:
1984_Farm
3
Feb 27, 2018
bookmark_border
Are these " electro capacitive switches" basically Topre switches? I really love the RF 87U typing experience, does this compare to it favorably?
Feb 27, 2018
travdump
237
Feb 27, 2018
bookmark_border
This is poor-man's-Topre. With a dome-swap, it can be almost as good, but Realforce boards knock it out of the park.
Feb 27, 2018
1984_Farm
3
Feb 27, 2018
bookmark_border
Ah I see, it is a pass for me then :(
Feb 27, 2018
elvper
24
Feb 27, 2018
bookmark_border
Some people think they're better than "real" Topres, others do not. I do not have a real Topre myself though, but I'm very satisfied of my Plum keyboard. I couldn't say anything bad about it. Most complaints I've seen about Plum keyboards and 30g actuation ... come from people who haven't even tried either... Much of the anti-Plum wave you often see is solely based on herd mentality and the ridiculous higher quality perception when something is expensive. It's like with games, people are more likely to think a game has a high quality (and play it longer) when they've paid a lot for it compared to when they've gotten it for a discounted price.
The wording "travdump" used speak volumes "this is poor-man's-Topre" -> the suggestion something is bad...because it's cheap. Thus, my advice is to look at some real reviews (Youtube) and to then make up your mind rather than to listen to the popular opinion given by people of whom most haven't even tried a Plum keyboard.
What I like most about the Plum over the real Topres is the sound, the Plum makes a lower sound which is a looooot less annoying (I hate sharp sounds).
Feb 27, 2018
1984_Farm
3
Feb 27, 2018
bookmark_border
Great, thanks for the tip.
Feb 27, 2018
mattstermh
81
Feb 27, 2018
bookmark_border
They're different. These are less tactile (if at all) but still incredibly satisfying to type on.
Feb 27, 2018
travdump
237
Feb 27, 2018
bookmark_border
I've heard them get called "Linear Topre." I'm sure they're all well and great if you like low actuations and low tactility, but they won't be for everyone.
Feb 27, 2018
mattstermh
81
Feb 27, 2018
bookmark_border
With 55g these feel identical to topre.
Feb 27, 2018
JimDetroit
122
Feb 28, 2018
bookmark_border
I have two Plum's. They are incredibly satisfying to type on. Smooth, soft bottom-out, and that lovely "thock" sound at the bottom. Very satisfying and easy to type on. They are approximately the same weighting as a Cherry Red, in my estimation. I highly recommend this keyboard.
Feb 28, 2018
consolation
742
Mar 1, 2018
bookmark_border
I have used both - Topre boards are lot more solid and substantial feeling and the switches have tighter tolerances so they rattle less. The RealForce keyboards feel more dense and stiffer, while the Plum doesn't feel bad, it doesn't exude the same sense of quality and gravitas that an old school RealForce does. Having said that, it's on par for the modernised RGB RealForces.
Typing wise they are similar to 30g Topres, mostly linear; modded to heavier domes; they feel similar to HHKB - oddly as they are plate mounted like RFs, I expected them to be more like a Novatouch. Actually, they remind me of unmodded NTs with better keycaps. OG Topre keycaps are much better quality, but they are better than the RGB ones. (Plus, you get cherry mounts - that's good as far as keycap choice and bad because you don't get the rock like stability of Topre mount.)
Overall, it's an excellent board for the price. What's telling, however, is that everyone I know who got one went on to get an 86 or 87 RF and wouldn't go back.
Mar 1, 2018
elvper
24
Mar 2, 2018
bookmark_border
The Realforce one costs 3 x as much. Too much in order for me to be willing to try it, especially considering I'm happy with my Plum. The reason they don't go back might also (partially) be to blame on the fact that they've shelled out a large sum on the Realforce, thus even if both would be as good psychologically they'd be a lot more likely to keep using the Realforce. Unless I'd have the opportunity to try a Realforce before buying I certainly won't buy one. Since I'm very happy with my Topre I highly doubt the 3 x higher cost is worth it. Plus from Youtube videos it appears the real Topres have a much more annoying and louder sound.
Ideally I'd want a Topre (clone) which has an lower or adjustable actuation point and with a higher customization capability (software) than a Plum (I don't know the options for Topre).
Mar 2, 2018
mrkantz
120
Mar 4, 2018
bookmark_border
I have this board along side a HHKB, RF87, and FC660C. The HHKB was dome swapped to BKE Heavy with BKE Extremes under the modifiers. The Plum (Mislabeled, it's actually a Niz. Plum is their line of MX boards.) is a little too light for my tastes, but as far as build quality/feel/mx sliders goes, this board makes the other Topre boards seem a bit overpriced IMO. I still prefer the real Topre boards, but the Niz is very much worth the money.
Mar 4, 2018
JohnCouchman
18
May 28, 2018
bookmark_border
Oh, thanks. Was thinking of giving this a shot cuz of the price, but I already have a Realforce.
May 28, 2018
baesex
220
Jun 18, 2018
bookmark_border
i prefer plum switches to topre personally
Jun 18, 2018
View Full Discussion