Click to view our Accessibility Statement or contact us with accessibility-related questions
Showing 1 of 5 conversations about:
Enekk
53
Mar 4, 2019
bookmark_border
Note: I do not own this teapot, but have owned three different cast iron teapots (people know I like tea and give them to me as gifts). I wanted to talk a bit about cast iron teapots for anyone that is on the fence about purchasing one of these. If you already know you love cast iron teapots, this post is probably not for you. Cast iron teapots got popular in the US partially due to a desire to up-sell people wondering into high-sales-pressure tea purveyors (e.g. Teavana). I used to visit these stores and heard all sorts of claims about cast iron ranging from the true (heat retention) to inane claims about health benefits (e.g. "iron leaches into the water" - obvious BS as these need to be enameled or they would rust easily). So, let's get into the goods and bads of cast iron for tea (and this pot in particular): ## Good
  • Heat Retention: This pot will retain heat longer than a tin or glass pot, but it must be properly warmed first. Warming requires filling the pot with hot water and letting the metal warm up, dumping (or reheating) that water, and then adding the water you actually want to brew with into the vessel. If you do not heat the pot first, it will sap a huge amount of heat from the brewing water.
  • Style: Subjective, sure, but these look really nice and will impress your guests.
## Neutral
  • Capacity: This is a HUGE pot, holding 1L of water. This is a lot of tea to drink in one go and reduces the chances you will want to re-brew the leaves (a good idea if you are buying good tea). On the other hand, if you are serving a bunch of guests, the capacity might be welcome.
  • Heating: This is a teapot, not a kettle. You will likely damage the pot if you heat the actual vessel. Very few teapots are also kettles, so I would say this is fairly reasonable, but people see cast iron and their minds immediately fill with visions of cooking over an open fire.
## Bad
  • Brewing Basket: The design of the brewing basket means you will need to fill this up almost all the way every time you use it or risk crowding the tea leaves or under-hydrating them. It is also a pain (enjoy the burned fingers) to get the brewing basket out, which you must do to prevent over brewing of the leaves.
  • Weight: Do I need to explain that cast iron is heavy? Take that weight and add 1L of water.
  • Pouring: The handle is very nice on this pot, but you will have to do 100% of the pouring action with your wrists. How hot the pot gets means you can't stabilize the pot with your hands and the weight means it is very hard on your wrists to properly tilt the pot. Add to this that the lids, unless perfect, have a tendancy to shift and fall off; the heat of the lid means you don't want to touch it, but you have to unless you want to drop a cast iron lid on your teaware. The spout, close to the body and short, means you will have to tilt quite a bit to get a proper pour.
  • Cleaning: You will need to clean and dry this pot as soon as you are done using it and make sure it is stored somewhere dry. Of course, everyone cleans everything they use immediately after use, but if you are one of the few people in the world who don't, stay away from this. Even the slightest damage to the enamel will mean you will have to work very hard to prevent rusting. Good thing this is nice and light, easy to not drop...
  • Heat Retention: Yes, this was on the Good list. The thing about heat retention is that it means you will need to be more careful with how you brew. With more traditional brewing vessels (mugs, gaiwans, 'normal' teapots), the heat loss means that you have more room for error before your tea turns from sweet to bitter. With high heat retention, you need to know the leaves you are brewing well (every tea, even within a single picking, has variability in how long you need to brew it). The other downside of heat retention is that more heat means more of the volatile flavor and scent compounds will change or escape while the pot rests (again, unless you pour all 1L of tea as soon as it is ready).
## Wat!?
  • Heat distribution: "Because it distributes heat more evenly, cast iron is an excellent choice for getting every bit of flavor you can from your favorite teas." What!? You are submerging leaves in hot water. There is no barrier for heat distribution. If we were applying heat to this, sure, that'd be a consideration, but we aren't. Even if we were heating in this, I encourage people to actually look up heat distribution and cast iron; it might retain heat well, but it isn't the most even cooking surface.
Clearly, I'm not a cast iron pot fan. It is ok if you are, but I think there are better options for most use cases. Most of you won't want to brew with gaiwans or actual Chinese teapots (generally sub 200ml), but if you must use a western style pot, I think something that weighs less or is less expensive (though this pot is quite reasonable) is a better option. You can even add heat retention to a 'normal' pot by adding a tea cozy. That was a lot, I hope it is helpful to someone.
Mar 4, 2019
BIGGUY4x4
73
Mar 5, 2019
bookmark_border
EnekkAny recommendations?
Mar 5, 2019
Enekk
53
Mar 5, 2019
bookmark_border
BIGGUY4x4@BIGGUY4x4 I don't have a specific recommendation as you should find a pot that suits you. I am partial to Forlife teapots as they are well constructed and have one of the best infuser designs around. Just don't buy too large a pot (rebrew instead of brewing too much) and make sure the handle feels good and is on the side of the pot (the solution to the 'how do I do a controlled pour with a heavy object' question). If you are looking to get way deep into tea, I'd suggest looking up gongfu tea on YouTube; watch the videos by Crimson Lotus, Teahouse Ghost, or Mei Leaf (though beware the latter's marketing tactics).
Mar 5, 2019
Mr.AnnoyingKnowItAll
192
May 27, 2019
bookmark_border
EnekkI love you for typing this out, fellow tea lover.
May 27, 2019
Albert.A
109
May 28, 2019
bookmark_border
EnekkOk, i own this tea pot and few thing i would like to sate out are not even relevant:
  1. 1L pot isn't that big if you are a true tea lover, if you think its too much for you , skip it and don't even buy a pot ...
  2. The pot is heavy but i never came across a problem of dropping it or the lid as tilting it require a low angle to get a good pour.
  3. The handle is rigid and you don't need to stabilize anything while pouring
  4. The enamel coating won't get any damage from hot water inside, unless you using some metal utensils for mixing the tea inside(I don't know why you would even do it) and it will take a lot of time and a lot of mixing to even scratch it, not talking about breaking the coating and reaching the bare metal underneath.
  5. cleaning isn't a problem, when you are brewing tea, you should always do it with clean water this way you wont get Tea Staining
  6. Even if you water is dirty and you get some tea staining, it doesn't stick to the enamel coating ( didn't happen for me yet even after leaving the tea inside for a day or two , yeap i had few occasions )
  7. The heat retention is great, the tea tastes great and i didn't had problem with a tea overcooking in the pot, and i usually always do leave the leafs inside and don't even remove them until I'm done drinking (on the second pour after heating up the pot i would just add slightly less warm water)
The only #Bad for me would be : That the handle would get too warm to hold for long time when pouring as when i brew the tea i would use a towel to wrap the pot to help it a little more with heat retention and it require the handle to be in a collapsed state so it gets warm
(Edited)
May 28, 2019
Enekk
53
May 29, 2019
bookmark_border
Albert.AI think that I more than qualify as a tea lover, it is just that my goals might be a bit different than yours. While I would argue that 1L is a lot, it isn't outrageous for Western style brewing. I don't want to get into the merits of Western style vs Chinese style, but let me just say that my brewing vessel of choice is ~120ml. In that size vessel I use 8g of tea (no, that's not a typo) and I brew the same leaves 15 or so times in a day (starting with infusions that can be as quick as 5 seconds). Chinese style brewing is about extracting the best bits of a tea over a journey, where as Western style tends to be more about volume and consistent product. If 1L works for you, great. I would suggest even Western style brewing fans would be better served with a smaller pot and rebrewing the same leaves two or three times (with an additional minute or two each time). Do what you like, learn your equipment, and enjoy.
May 29, 2019
sepocket
0
Apr 27, 2020
bookmark_border
Enekkthanks for the comment! Gives me something to think about!
Apr 27, 2020
View Full Discussion