I ordered and received a Troy (salmon) and Zach (navy) shirt in medium. I normally wear medium, and the shirt fits well in the chest and shoulders. However, the cuffs are really small: they barely get around my watch and rolling up the sleeves was uncomfortable.
The material itself feels really soft and comfortable, and the colours are nice. The buttons are nice. Overall it's pretty good but not fantastic.
I would enter this as a review but don't know how.