Click to view our Accessibility Statement or contact us with accessibility-related questions
betarepeating
43
Aug 4, 2015
Can someone explain the appeal of this drop to me?
Ignoring the mistaken copy (why would you want a cordless soldering iron anyways) this is one of the worst massdrops i've seen in a while.
Tips are expensive, as the Massdrop guy commented above the unit heats up over time, which doesn't scream quality to me. Reviews are scarce and their website just wants to boast about how much smaller it is. It seems like they shrunk this thing down out of some obsession with "looking cool" with no regard for why anyone would want that. Soldering is a process that typically requires sitting at a workbench with good stability and grip. If you're really that strapped for room on your workbench, maybe this is for you, but for anyone else I don't really see what advantage this brings. And it may be personal preference, but I'd prefer a thicker grip anyways.
Either spend half the price of this drop to get an el-cheapo iron or fork over another $30 to get a quality iron that will last you a lifetime (and come with an actual stand!)
"I wish my soldering iron would fit in my pocket" said no one ever.
Hibbidydibbidy
5
Aug 4, 2015
betarepeating1) Your on your back, climbing under the dash of your car, and need to connect some wires together (although crimping might be better in that application 2) your making repairs to doorbell wiring, up on a ladder. "I wish my soldering iron would fit in my tool belt, and work without mains power" said people who fix things, as opposed to building them. Now I have no idea about the merits of this particular iron, but I can see many use cases for it (if it works..)
acidboogie
13
Aug 4, 2015
betarepeatingI did some work a few years ago building instrument panels for a power plant's training simulator. Each panel was about 10 feet tall, 19" rack-mount wide, and 4 feet deep and had between 400-800 components each. It was far too cramped inside to use the Weller station we had in the workshop, so we had to use butane-burner soldering irons which weren't exactly small, but portable enough to get inside the panels.
There absolutely are situations where you'd want a decently portable soldering iron such as this, and just because you've never needed an impressively small iron it doesn't mean no one has ever needed one.
6EQUJ5
459
Aug 5, 2015
betarepeatingI wish my soldering iron would fit in my pocket.
betarepeating
43
Aug 5, 2015
acidboogieboth you and @Hibbidydibbidy are making a good case for a cordless soldering iron, but... this isn't cordless -_-
I can certainly concede that there are portable applications, though I'm skeptical that most of the people on here will need it for that. And most of the "oh look its so small and portable" arguments don't hold water when you realize you're still leashed to an outlet by a clunky power brick...
Either get a (much less expensive) soldering iron like this [1] and be just as portable, or buy a much nicer soldering station like this [2] and have it last a lifetime, or go get a butane iron like this [3] if you really need portability.
If you're really in the intersection of all three where you need something portable but have outlets nearby and want it to be good but not amazing and want it to heat fast but then dont need to use it for long periods then I guess this iron is for you.
[1] http://www.amazon.com/ECG-J-025-Watt-Soldering-Iron/dp/B0002GLZM4 [2] http://www.amazon.com/Weller-WES51-Analog-Soldering-Station/dp/B000BRC2XU [3] http://www.amazon.com/Weller-P2KC-Professional-Self-igniting-Soldering/dp/B000WOHSHM/ref=cm_cr_pr_product_top
6EQUJ5
459
Aug 5, 2015
betarepeatingI own a Hakko 936 already, and I own a pencil tip Weller WM120 and an assorted other wattage types of Radio Shack plug-in soldering irons which I threw out after I realized how much it sucked to have soldering irons where you cannot control the heat. The problem with those plug-in pencil tip iron is that you can't control how hot they get so they become unreliable when melting a lot of small joints as you have to wait much longer for the tip to heat up again or they just ultimately fail. Pretty much my Weller WM120 is now unreliable and sits in my toolbox somewhere unused, it worked great for like the first 5 times and even after cleaning the tip it cannot melt my solder.
1. Out of the question, there is no way to control the temps 2. Already own a Hakko 936. Why not save yourself $23 and get a Hakko clone? Pretty much just a TrakPower sticker over a Hakko unit: http://www.amazon.com/Trakpower-TKPR0950-TK950-Soldering-Station/dp/B0051VD82U
3. You sacrifice a thin profile and live with bulkiness and portability because it needs a butane tank, a lot of mixed reviews with the Dremel portable one too even if that was an option
For anyone considering getting a soldering iron I would recommend getting one where you can control the temperature. With plug-in irons if it doesn't get hot enough the solder doesn't melt (especially 60/40) and if gets too hot you damage the component you're trying to solder or you damage the PCB traces. A temperature controlled soldering iron is the way to go if you're working with fine electronics. My temperature controlled Hakko 936 soldering station has been the only reliable soldering iron I have so far.
For smaller projects and fine electronics it only makes sense that people jump on this drop.
betarepeating
43
Aug 6, 2015
6EQUJ5To be clear, option 1 is 1/4th the price of this item for a reason. It's a bargain option for beginners and for people who very rarely solder.