Click to view our Accessibility Statement or contact us with accessibility-related questions
Showing 1 of 13 conversations about:
Stick
10
Aug 19, 2017
bookmark_border
I understand this question... I have only been backpacking since late 2009 and I distinctly remember trying to figure out what gear to buy... it was a mess! One of the first things I did was join a couple of backpacking related internet forums and begin asking questions. At that time, it was the forums at Backpacker.com. While I still made some bad choices back then, I actually did get a good bit of good information that helped me not only make gear decisions, but to go father than this and think about the trip and what it would require rather than just the gear itself. I also joined the forums at WhiteBlaze since it was specific to the Appalachian Trail, and that is where I was interested in hiking.
Some time later with the help of one of the Backpacker.com forum members I joined the Backpackgeartest.org site. Yes, this allowed me to get some free gear, but it wasn't as simple as just sticking my hand out. Over the course of a couple of years, I received items I found I liked, and items I didn't like. However, what the editors there taught me was how to write an honest review. I learned not just to regurgitate what the (usually lacking) product page told me, but to actually use the product and find these things out for myself. This included providing actual measured specs (which is something that I find lacking in so many gear :reviews"... instead, it is a simple reprint of what the product page lists, which is usually not correct) as well as how the product performed... both on it's own, and more importantly as part of a system (which I find to be very important, and how I try to direct my reviews).
Most importantly though, Backpackgeartest.org taught me not to project. We were not allowed to use words such as "you" and we were not allowed to try and imply that just because something did or did not work for me, did not mean it would or would not work for someone else. This was hard at first, but it taught me to focus more on the product rather than trying to sell it to someone else, or for the company with my review. But this is also what made me start looking at something first on it's own, but how would it incorporate into my entire system... because when it comes to gear, I don't think any one thing is necessarily on it's own... it's part of a larger system.
My problem was that I live in NE Mississippi. Around here, we don't have gear stores that I can walk into and lay my hands on items, and there definitely aren't places that are remotely near me that I can get out and backpack... These things are a struggle for a working father with a family, but I make time when I can. However, because of the subpar reviews I generally found on gear, I did decide to create my own blog. At first, it was to share my experiences while backpacking, but I also began posting my own product reviews, and then it also became something of a personal journal that showed my progression of my gear choices, my trips, and some deep thoughts about both of those things... And I choose to share this with the public.
Since that time, like others, I have been contacted by way more companies that I cared for offering to send items for "review." About 80% of these were turned down simply because they weren't really related to actual backpacking, or because they didn't align with my goals. Before I ever decided if I would allow someone to send me something I first decided if it was something that I was interested enough in that I would spend my own money on. If not, I passed... I didn't want a bunch of junk cluttering up my home just because it was free, and I wasn't interested in trying to sell it after the review. At one point in time, I also became an ambassador for a well known cottage backpacking company, but it was short-lived and I never even received anything from them. Since then, I have no longer been affiliated with any backpacking company, and while there are some that I absolutely love (and is obvious from my site) I actually prefer not to be affiliated with them... I don't like feeling like I owe any company anything (unless I buy something from them...)
Since 2009 I have come a long way with backpacking and spent way more money than I ever thought I would to simply walk in the woods. Since then though I have found things that work for me, and things that don't. When I review items on my blog/YouTube I was always upfront about if I paid for the item, or if it was something I was provided with for a review. As well, when I review something, I like to get involved, and that usually takes some time. I go into detail about first off, why I choose an item, what I expected of it, and how it would play a part in the rest of my gear system. I also like to focus on where and how I plan to use an item, and what I expect of it for me. When folks comment or ask question, I prefer to discuss it with them, not necessarily to recommend it or not. I like to think that I am merely expanding the information found on product pages and talking with folks about that to help them have a better idea about something... This is what I was looking for when I started out, and is what I try to offer now.
Anyway, sorry for the long drawn out reply... like I said, I usually get somewhat involved with my reviews... I often get comments on my sites complaining that I won't get to the point or what not.. that's fine. I know in depth reviews/talk isn't for everyone, but there are a lot of folks out there that benefit from it too...
Anyway, to answer your question, mostly I go on BPL for info now... It seems like it isn't what it once was back in the day, but there is still some good information found on the site (just have to read through all the bickering). I still visit the Whiteblaze forums when I need specific right now info about the AT. And there are also a few blogs that I sometimes visit for specific things, such as Hiking Jim's page.
~Stick~
Aug 19, 2017
View Full Discussion
Related Posts
Trending Posts in More Community Picks