Showing 1 of 3 conversations about:
steelclaw1313
1
Nov 15, 2017
bookmark_border
I guess my next question would be..
Is a DAC and Amp combo like some other tech combos where it's not as good if they're in one unit? So, is it better to get them separately or is a combo usually sufficient? Well.. I guess "sufficient" is a bit subjective.. but y'all get it.
Nov 15, 2017
shimage
218
Nov 15, 2017
bookmark_border
"Sufficient" is entirely dependent on your budget. This stuff isn't difficult to design or manufacture. All-in-one is going to be fine. Separate is also fine. They are all going to measure the same, for the most part, and in a blind test they will also sound the same. Sighted, there is a good chance you will hear differences. Sighted listening is, I guess, more important than blind in the sense that that is how you will be listening to music. But I won't give you advice based on what your brain may or may not make up out of thin air. Lots of people like to do this, but for me it seems disingenuous. My advice is to always demo before buying, or to buy from a place that allows returns (eg, schiit). That way your satisfaction is in your hands alone.
As for specifications (I didn't see anyone go through this below), the ones usually given are frequency response, THD+N, crosstalk and for amps probably power output as well. Less often you will see output impedance and IMD measurements.
Frequency response should be flat. If it isn't then something is wrong and you should probably avoid it (dac or amp). That's all there is to say about that.
For distortion, it is surprisingly difficult to hear distortion of any kind <1% in anything other than optimal conditions. Total system distortion <0.1% is attainable, though, and not particularly difficult to do.
THD is harmonic distortion. Basically, when fed a sine wave, any periodic deviation from that in the output (meaning it happens the same in each wave) is going to be captured by THD. Clipping and crossover distortion are examples of harmonic distortion. For THD, DACs don't have as much to do, so usually you expect the distortion to be lower (say, <0.01%). Ideally, they will give THD as a function of frequency (with stated output levels), but this is fairly uncommon. One manufacturer that does is Topping, and you can see from their graph of the D30 that THD tops out at around 0.0008% (THD for signals >10kHz are irrelevant). For amps, I would say <0.1% is probably fine, but I expect <0.01% under load (that is, driving 30Ohm or so headphones) over the entire spectrum. This is not difficult to find, and in fact most decent cellphones manage this easily.
Intermodulated distortion is distortion caused by the presence of multiple frequencies at the same time (a fairly common situation in music, obviously). IMD is usually higher, but it often isn't reported, or if it is, they don't report it properly (what is the load, what are the two frequencies used, what are the levels for each?). Ideally, you would have measurements for a variety of pairs of frequencies, but this is never done except by individuals curious about their gear. As with THD, this should be <0.01%. A lot of cellphones have problems with this, but some do fine (Samsung, LG, Apple). Pretty much any desktop amp should be able to manage this, but some little ones, like iFi's products, have issues somehow. The popularity of the dragonfly suggests that it isn't terribly audible, but still... value for money and all that.
Power output doesn't really matter, so long as it gets loud enough. A gain switch is nice to have, if you have a variety of headphones with different impedances and efficiencies. Keep in mind that even very inefficient headphones need at most several milliwatts to get to ear-bustingly loud volumes. If your source doesn't put out linelevel, then you'll need a bit more gain. However, the importance of power output is usually overstated. The other thing to worry about is that if you listen at very low volumes, or have too much gain, you may end up all the way on the quiet end of the volume pot. The problem with this is that that is where pots have noticeable channel imbalances. You can always stick an in-line attenuator somewhere so this isn't that big a problem, honestly.
Output impedance is a bit of a wash. Standard practice is that output impedance should be a factor of 8-10 less than the impedance of the load (ie, the headphone). If it is not, weird things can happen (usually, a boost to the bass/lower mids). For example, this resistance can mess with crossover circuits found in multi-BA IEMs. Dynamic headphones pretty much always have a resonance in the bass with a commensurate increase in the impedance; this is what causes the bass boost with OTL tube amps. Some people like the weird things that happen. Some headphones are designed with sizable output impedances in mind (eg, both Sennheiser's and Beyerdynamic's headphone amps have ~100Ohm output impedance). So ... buy whatever you want. It bears mentioning, though, that planars are resistive loads and aren't affected by non-zero output impedance aside from a drop in overall volume level.
Crosstalk doesn't matter. Even the worst amps have crosstalk ~-50dB, which is inaudible and isn't going to affect soundstage or imaging in a real way. Could have effects in sighted listening, but whatever. No one complains about crosstalk in loudspeaker systems.
Jitter. This used to be a problem for poorly designed dacs, but it isn't anymore. Don't worry about it. Even the lowly Fiio E10 (long ago superseded by the E10k) has good enough jitter rejection.
I almost forgot! phase response! Nobody cares. Look at the phase response of the HD800 and tell me that it matters. The O2 is only off by 8deg, and even then only in low frequencies where it doesn't matter. Airist really wants you to care, but you shouldn't.
Nov 15, 2017
View Full Discussion
Related Posts
bookmark_border
timko
Can jds Labs atom handle DT990 250/600 OHM?
If it can handle dt990 600ohm and/or 250ohm
Dec 9, 2019
Questions
bookmark_border
ElectronicVices
HE6se vs. Arya
Haven't seen much talk on here regarding these newer releases from Hifiman. I've been a huge fan of the HE-500 for the last 6 or so years. It is still my favorite sound signature even with the 20+ pairs that have followed it. When the original HE-6 was still in production I didn't have much interest due to cost and limited options for amping it properly. Once I had picked up amplifiers capable of driving it properly, and rectified myself to the >$1K cost, it became quite scarce due to all the Code modding going on. Now with the HE6se I have a chance to purchase it NIB again (although at a much higher cost). I was all set to drop $1800 on the 6se when the Arya came to my attention. Now I am a bit stuck in deciding between the two. I am a big fan of extended bass, fairly neutral response leaning a shade warm if I have to pick a side, amplification is not a concern. Anyone have time with either (preferably both) of these offerings? Thanks to anyone who might be able to...
Mar 5, 2019
Questions
bookmark_border
zweb
What wifi music systems do you use?
I listen to music pretty much from internet stations like spotify, youtube music etc using wifi phone/laptop and using wireless headsets. But looking at various comments on drop, I feel I am obviously missing something. I do not think I want to go back to CDs and wired systems. What are the some really good wireless music systems I should look at? I am ok with cost in few thousand USD.
Dec 12, 2019
Questions
bookmark_border
dematted
Amp to Pair with Focal Elex
Hello. I'm the proud owner of a Focal Elex and I'm wondering what amp pairs well with it. For reference, I currently own a Schiit Magni 3 and JDS atom, as well as a topping D10 dac. I'm looking for something that will smooth out the sound a bit, bring vocals forward somewhat, and increase the bass quantity. I'm considering the following amps: Schiit Asgard 3 Cavalli Tube Hybrid Vali 2 Valhalla 2 Liquid Carbon X Lyr 3 My budget is 300 dollars, and I'm very willing to look at used items!
Dec 8, 2019
Questions
bookmark_border
Rajahindustani
Wireless Gaming Headset
I am always looking for a good wireless gaming headset. Why don't drop bring some decent wireless earphones ,headphones and especially wireless Gaming Headset.
Dec 7, 2019
Questions
bookmark_border
Azeendeen
What is a good DAC to pair with massdrop THX AAA linear AMP
I am looking at buying the THX AAA linear AMP on massdrop. However I don't know what DAC I should get with it .I got a budget of 350$ same price as the amp
Nov 27, 2018
Questions
Trending Posts in Audiophile
bookmark_border
zweb
What wifi music systems do you use?
I listen to music pretty much from internet stations like spotify, youtube music etc using wifi phone/laptop and using wireless headsets. But looking at various comments on drop, I feel I am obviously missing something. I do not think I want to go back to CDs and wired systems. What are the some really good wireless music systems I should look at? I am ok with cost in few thousand USD.
Dec 12, 2019
Questions
bookmark_border
timko
Can jds Labs atom handle DT990 250/600 OHM?
If it can handle dt990 600ohm and/or 250ohm
Dec 9, 2019
Questions
bookmark_border
dematted
Amp to Pair with Focal Elex
Hello. I'm the proud owner of a Focal Elex and I'm wondering what amp pairs well with it. For reference, I currently own a Schiit Magni 3 and JDS atom, as well as a topping D10 dac. I'm looking for something that will smooth out the sound a bit, bring vocals forward somewhat, and increase the bass quantity. I'm considering the following amps: Schiit Asgard 3 Cavalli Tube Hybrid Vali 2 Valhalla 2 Liquid Carbon X Lyr 3 My budget is 300 dollars, and I'm very willing to look at used items!
Dec 8, 2019
Questions
bookmark_border
joeftan
DIY hybrid ear tips
[image] I’ve never really liked foam tips, because I find it a pain to roll, insert, then have to hold the IEMs in place, until the foam expands. I like using silicone tips, but do miss the isolation of the foam tips. I’ve been looking for hybrid foam/silicone tips for a while, and haven’t found any readily available. I do like the isolation provided by multi-flange tips, and find the Shure triple-flange tips the most comfortable (not too sticky) for repeated use. I do cut off the smallest flange because it’s more comfortable, and doesn’t roll off the highs much. Well, I was experimenting with tips for my Etymotics, and found that the stalk of the triple flange Shure tips, perfectly fits snugly into the center of the Mercury (4.9mm) Dekoni Bulletz foam tips, thus making them hybrid tips. You do need the large size foam tips to fill out the Shure tips. Using the hybrid tips is the same as just using the Shure tips, but the isolation is quite a bit better. No modding...
Dec 8, 2019
General
bookmark_border
Noa_Valentine11
Question: Why can't I ship the Sennheiser 6XX to Australia?
When I go to Checkout with these Headphones, or any others, Australia doesn't appear as a country available.
Dec 7, 2019
Questions
bookmark_border
underpickled
USB DAC with stereo TRS outputs + Headphone jack
I've got an MBox Pro driving my KRK Rokit 8 monitors via TRS cable, and it's great, but there haven't been new drivers in ages and it has to be restarted frequently at best (because the sound will cut out or just not come through) and the drivers cause BSODs occasionally at worst. Since I don't really use it for recording anymore, I'm hoping to find something much simpler that uses USB instead of firewire and would hopefully be more stable. Everything offered on Drop so far seems to be RCA and I'd much prefer to have a balanced connection. Any suggestions for what I'm looking for? Thanks in advance!
Dec 6, 2019
Questions
bookmark_border
rastus
Gaming Headphones
Someone is making a "better mousetrap for sound" I got a set of their protoype MEMS IEM's to try out... you will be able to hear a mouse coming... one clawed paw softly scratching after the other... mouse claw detail... https://www.usound.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/TaygeteBrochure_Web.pdf [image] Wot he said,, well this is partway there... https://drop.com/talk/2405/digital-sonic-fluidity
Dec 6, 2019
General