Click to view our Accessibility Statement or contact us with accessibility-related questions

Wrist Check

more_vert
Every serious watch person has at least one homage or knockoff. Here's mine: An excellent $20 G-SHOCK homage from China.
search
6
13
remove_red_eye
5K
Bugxy
2065

search
close
DoneItDesign
81
Aug 22, 2017
I hope one day you can afford an authentic Casio, sir.
Bugxy
2065
Aug 22, 2017
ltopper
1113
Nov 1, 2017
DoneItDesignThe perfect follow-up here..
DoneItDesign
81
Aug 21, 2017
This statement seems a little contradictory, I'm unsure why serious watch people would include a knock-off Casio in their collection. This watch appears far from excellent.
richardfung
7
Aug 21, 2017
> but you felt compelled to address it as if I had posted a knockoff
I'm not sure what I said which made you read it that way but I was actually trying to disagree with your definitions of knockoff, counterfeit, and homage.
> Did not want to say this before but I am in fact a lawyer
Unfortunately I don't fully understand how this is relevant given I was never trying to imply the legality of anything and you yourself said knockoff is not a legal term. Perhaps homage is?
> I do know the difference between a counterfeit and a homage, and it comes down to what I described before.
Again, I do not believe countefeit is the same as knockoff. Quote from wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counterfeit_consumer_goods): " A "knockoff" is a colloquial term which describes products that copy or imitate the physical appearance of other products, but which do not copy the brand name or logo of a trademark. They may, or may not, be illegal under trademark laws."
Or in other words, not copying name does not imply not a knockoff.
I don't know why you keep trying to tell me what a homage is when I'm saying I disagree with your definitions. Unless there's some legal definition for homage which is different from the English definition (which is something along the lines of pay respects to as I posted earlier), using the same design for a cheap watch but without their logo isn't a homage. There's no respect being paid, it's just stealing of design in an attempt to make money.
Bugxy
2065
Aug 21, 2017
richardfungLet's agree to disagree. This debate is beside the point of my post.
Related Posts
Trending Posts in More Community Picks