The X52 is great and so much better than the others... If you can afford it. My GamerStorm has held up very well, replacing my broken pump on my H100i GTX that almost fried my mobo. Never going corsair for cooling again.
Even so if you replaced it with the same cooler there is lttle chance it would happen agian, can't rule a company for a mistake,my iPhone 7 broke2 days after release, didn't stop me getting another one and had no issues since