OnePunchManComfort is a difficult metric to quantify as it is so subjective, but I will say that these shoes are objectively better than the two brands you mention. They also have a quilted insole, which certainly looks comfy in pictures!
OnePunchManWe're using the same quilted heel cup we use in our dress shoes, which you can see a picture of on our website on any oxford or derby product. Our insoles are a pretty standard 1/8 inch with a layer of cork. Many members have found that the shoes and boots break in very quickly! If you have any questions, feel free to shoot me an email at hello@cobbler-union.com and we can talk/hop on the phone!