Click to view our Accessibility Statement or contact us with accessibility-related questions
FairDinkum
57
Oct 12, 2014
Can't decide between this and the Vanishing Point. Halp!
nioriatti
7
Oct 12, 2014
FairDinkumThe Stargazer is smaller, and has a cap. When posted, it is about the same length as the vanishing point. Not sure, if the vanishing point also has a gold nib, but if it doesn't, get the Stargazer, because it has a gold nib. They use the same ink cartridges and convertors. I'm waiting for the drop to hit $99, then I'll jump on this one. I think the weights are different, because I think they are made of different materials.
nioriatti
7
Oct 12, 2014
FairDinkumI just looked. They both have gold nibs. The Vanishing Point has an 18k golda and this one has 14k gold. Thus, the vanishing point will be a bit softer. The biggest reason I don't want the Vanishing Point is because of the location of clip on the barrel. With the way I hold my pens, my fingers would be wrapped around the clip and it would probably be very uncomfortable, but that all depends on how you write. Hope I could help!
cpmcnamara
84
Oct 13, 2014
nioriattiI don't think the vanishing point will be "softer" (if you are assuming this means springier) because of the 18k gold nib. Typically, the opposite is true with nibs, i.e. sailor nibs are often 21K and almost always nails by design. The lack of less malleable metal in the higher gold content nibs mean that they can not be designed to bend as much without being sprung.
That said, the higher gold content may result in smoother writing, but that's questionable and probably has more to do with alignment. The big difference between these pens is obviously in the retractable nib design. If one doesn't want that, don't go with the VP as that's it's main selling point versus other pens.
This drop seems ok, but people can buy the Stella version directly from Japanese sellers for less on ebay. I think that's a better bet, as it's really the exact same pen.
KarlBlessing
130
Oct 16, 2014
cpmcnamara14K, 18K, Steel etc doesn't dictate how 'soft' the nib will be since you can have gold nibs (even 18K) that are hard as nails, or very soft depending on how the manufactures design them and what alloy mixing they're using for the non-gold portion of the nib. Likewise you can have steel nibs that are flexy, but most tend to be stiff.
So it's a bit of a myth to consider gold "soft", since it's just going to vary on how the manufacture designs/creates it. Though something like 21K has so much gold in it that there's not much room to control it's properties as it's 87.5% gold as opposed to 18K (75%) and 14K (58.5%).
I have a few 70s-80s era Pilot Elites that have 18K Nibs from a very firm/stiff "Posting" nib that has absolutely no line variation and can take a bit of pressure, to a 18K "Soft Fine" with some line variation.