These are really nice. The plastic is neither textured nor exactly smooth, it's sort of velvety, and the legends are big and pleasantly vintage looking (with a few problematic exceptions).
Some of the legends on the direction keys (which I'm not using) are quite sloppy. The only keys that look bad on my board are the greater than and less than, it looks like they're bottom-aligned like nobody thought this would look bad with the comma's descender. The numbers on the top row are also not quite lined up but not nearly as noticeable.
Overall though, these feel 100% and look 95%. I've got a set of the T0MB3RY SA Carbons coming (hopefully) later this year, looking forward to comparing.
I actually really like this keyset -- albeit, I'm not picky on keycaps. The quality is quite nice. They're smooth and have a nice slick feel to them. If you prefer matte keycaps, I would stay away from this, but I like them a lot. I got everything I purchased which was the base kit (TKL), Numpad, and the BY/YB novelties. All the legend fonts are pretty centered. The packaging was also nice!
Don't trust any of the renders, the keys are not silver and they don't have any cool tone at all; they are flat white and if anything they have a slightly warm tone.
The stepped caps lock in the "non-standard" set has an offset post rather than centered, which isn't mentioned anywhere and means I can't use it on my keyboard so that's pretty disappointing.
And finally, though this one I expected so I'm not knocking any stars off for it, the "all-in-one" set is not all; it only includes the ones in the picture, so you don't get the blue alphas or white non-standard or Excalibur metal.
Stepped keycaps historically are off-set. You'd have to find a pcb board that supports that. (I write this as I need to find a stepped caps lock for mine sadly).
After being a fan of the Fate series (and especially the Knight King - Artoria Pendragon), finally I'm getting this build on my desk with every part selected based on the image of her:
The color of the keys are very different from the photos here on the website.
I ordered these key caps expecting that the blues would be dark and the yellow would be a darker gold like in the pictures. After receiving them they look completely different and drop will not return them even though I have even taken them out of the original container. 100% would not recommend buying these and I’ll never be buying anything from drop ever again. They’ve lost a customer due to bad service.
So I got a non standard set that look used, BUT I brought it to Drops attention, and no questions asked, they replaced them with a brand new set with no defects whatsoever. Their customer service is top-notch. I am very happy. I only needed the set for the shift key, but I might buy another size keyboard and might need to use the other keys in it, so I wanted them all to look good. Here is a pic. Keep in mind, I ordered the other keycap set from a different site, so the only thing from drop in my photo is the right shift key. Looks great though!
Unique and good-looking keycap set in what I consider to be very attractive colors. Especially like the artisan enter key and high quality. If you like the SA profile, you won't be disappointed.