Free Standard Shipping in the US on orders over $99

What is the difference between Staggered and Ortholinear layouts

Oct 12, 20223974 VIEWS

We've already looked at a variety of sizes and layouts available in the mechanical keyboard world. There are a few more topics left to cover as we dive into the basics. This is the second of a handful of articles exploring the various aspects to consider for newcomers to this hobby.

Topics include:

Size/Layout
Staggered vs Ortholinear (you are here)
Low-Profile vs High-Profile
Build Quality

Staggered vs Ortholinear
What are Staggered and Ortholinear Layouts Before diving into the topic, a brief introduction is needed for those that might not know the terms. Staggered is a little easier to deduce from the word itself - keys are aligned vertically (going across a given row, the key to the left and right does not shift position up or down—in other words, the vertical rows are all in alignment) but are staggered horizontally (conversely, going up or down a given column, the keys above and below a key do shift position left or right). Ortholinear means that the keys are all aligned vertically as well as horizontally, most often in a perfect grid pattern. This is also sometimes referred to as a “matrix” layout, though this is less common in the keyboard hobby. There are also other types of staggering (uniform, symmetric, and columnar), but we won’t be covering those in this introductory article.

Image Credit: @HoffmanMyster

History of Staggered Layouts While not critical to understanding the difference between the two layout types, some history seems appropriate at this point. Feel free to skip below if you’d prefer. When typewriters were first developed, staggered layouts became a design necessity. Each key that the user pressed was connected to an arm (“typelever” or “keylever”) which was mechanically connected to the typebar. Pressing a given key causes the linkages to move such that the reversed character on the typebar is slammed into the ink-ribbon-covered paper, leaving that character inked onto the sheet.

Image Credit: @livingspeedbump (GMK_Andy) This array of physical levers and bars within the inner workings of the typewriter meant that the four (at the time) rows of keys must all be staggered by a quarter key-width in order to fit neatly alongside each other. And thus was born our staggered layout, remaining roughly unchanged in the nearly century and a half that has followed. Slightly less well-known than the origins of this staggered layout on the typewriter is an interesting stepping stone on the way to modern computers. Early computer input devices, particularly punch card machines like the IBM 029 shown below, used a sort of hybrid system of mechanical linkages found in typewriters and electrical matrices that would become standard later.

Image credit: @HoffmanMyster It’s difficult to show everything connected (it buttons up real nice and encloses the interesting bits), but these arms sticking out of the top are the equivalent of the typelevers found in typewriters. That’s where the similarities end, however, as the arms in this punch card keyboard connect to an array of other mechanical and electrical linkages to convert the keypress into an electrical signal that the machine can understand. This part of the process is still a bit of a mystery to me—it appears to use a combination of more basic switches closing along with a “chord” mechanism to check a smaller number of potential switches for a specific combination that would correspond to a given key.

Image credit: @HoffmanMyster Okay, enough historical digressions for now… Ortholinear Layouts The obvious follow-up question to all of this is, “why keep an old outdated standard if we don’t need to?” and the answer probably won’t surprise anyone—inertia. Changing standards is hard, and unless they absolutely must it’s really difficult to convince people to do so. You may look down at your keyboard and notice something though—depending on the size and layout of your keyboard, of course. All of the keys added after the age of the typewriter follow the ortholinear design language. On a full-size keyboard, for example, the numpad, arrow cluster, insert/delete cluster, and F-row (save for those middle keys, centered for symmetry) all fit into perfect ortholinear groupings. Expectedly, these keys were all worked into the standard keyboard layout after discrete keyswitches took over as the dominant actuation mechanism. While there was some experimentation into ortholinear layouts in the 1990s (Deskthority references the TypeMatrix line of keyboards in their wiki), the layout did not take off to any broad extent and remained a mere oddity and curiosity more than anything else.

Image Credit: Webwit at Deskthority In more recent years, many keyboard designers and hobbyists have pushed the envelope further and done a lot to help popularize ortholinear layouts to a broader audience. This progress comes as a result of more home-built keyboards (it’s easier to wire up a standard matrix or design an ortholinear PCB/plate than work in the standard staggering) and custom keycap sets (we have more control over our keycap legends than ever these days). Some early ortholinear keyboards offered commercially were the Planck and Preonic, from designer Jack Humbert.

Image Credit: @Sabao Since then, there have been countless ortholinear keyboards designed and released by community members. Most are one-off designs cooked up for a particular reason, but hey—that’s half the fun. If you haven’t looked into this world much, I recommend taking a look at some of the ortholinear posts on /r/mk. Clearly I am just scratching the surface of the topic here. If this interests you, I encourage you to dig a little deeper and share what you find in the comments below. Thanks for reading! Edit: Formatting, clarification about punch card machine

(Edited)

Vote

3.9K

Sort by: Newest

Oct 19, 2022

Not enough said about the avantages of ortho in my opinion. Especially when it comes to touch typing.

Lilalas

Oct 19, 2022

You did a good job explaining the history of these designs, but you did not go into the implications of what all this means for typing at all. My personal analysis: It doesn’t make a huge difference, but there are one or two keys that are easier to reach on ortho. (It would be nice if somebody could link diagrams showing the reachability score of each key.) Other than that, I think ortho is also easier to learn/remember the layout (though this is highly subjective).

quadibloc

Oct 18, 2022

An IBM 29 isn't a computer. It's a card punch. The cards with holes in them that it makes are then taken to a card reader attached to a computer. That way, programs or data put on cards with the card punch can be read into the computer much faster than people can type, and so the computer wasn't tied up while people were preparing programs or data for it.

HoffmanMyster

2618

Community

Oct 25, 2022

quadiblocVery true! I should have said "computer input devices", since that's really what the 029 is.

Vote

StormWasHere

Keyboard Club Member

Oct 12, 2022

I am here for the Ortho representation!!! We need more of it! We also need more ortho boards and more ortho keycap sets. There is nothing more heart wrenching then seeing an awesome set and not having enough 1U keycaps to fill my boards.

erickong

7381

Mech Keys Moderator

Oct 12, 2022

"This array of physical levers and bars within the inner workings of the typewriter meant that the four (at the time) rows of keys must all be staggered by a quarter key-width in order to fit neatly alongside each other. And thus was born our staggered layout, remaining roughly unchanged in the nearly century and a half that has followed. " That makes too much sense

HoffmanMyster

Mech Keys How-To - Table of Contents

As we publish more articles in the "Mech Keys How-To" series currently ongoing, navigating the various topics and finding previous articles will only become more difficult. This thread will serve as a table of contents to help add some structure to the whole project. Feel free to also suggest future topics in this thread, as it will surely be easier to identify gaps and opportunities for further exploration when viewing everything as a whole. Mechanical Keyboards Introductory Topics Mechanical vs Membrane Sizes and Layouts of Mechanical Keyboards Short Intro Into Split Keyboards (dovenyi) Staggered and Ortholinear Layouts Low-Profile vs High-Profile Keyboard Designs Build Materials and Other Case Design Considerations Selecting Your First Mechanical Keyboard (The_Manic_Geek) Keycaps Keycap Materials Keycap Profiles In Defense of MT3 (StoryBoardTech) How To Design a GMK Keycap Set (GMK_Andy) The GMK Color Matching Process (GMK_Andy) Switches Introduction to Mechanical...

Jan 24, 2023

Mech Keys

Guides

Drop Updates

TBNRnooch

Don't Buy A Mechanical Keyboard... Yet

My mechanical keyboard journey started when I fell into the rabbit hole around August 2020. Since then, I have tested over forty different switches, built or modified over twenty keyboards, and experimented with many different layouts. I usually carry a mechanical keyboard with me, and have built keyboards for friends and family members. Many consider mechanical keyboards superior to normal membrane keyboards due to their feel, sound, looks, layout options, software, and various customization options. While many swear by mechanical keyboards, they are expensive, and the landscape of mechanical keyboards is confusing and hard to navigate. That said, if you do decide to look into and possibly build one, here is some more information to guide you through the rabbit hole. The first thing you will probably notice while looking through videos about mechanical keyboards is the sound. Many people build their custom keyboards with sound in mind, and because of this there are endless jargon...

Nov 29, 2023

Mech Keys

Guides

ThereminGoatMK

About That List of Every Switch Ever…

Figure 1: While this is a good start from user destohfaeda, this isn't anywhere near complete... After having collected switches for almost five consecutive years now, I can say with confidence that everything switch related comes and goes in ever-looping cycles. Strong tactile bumps towards the start of the downstroke were once novel and popular, faded out of the limelight over the past few years, and are only just now starting to make a comeback. Huge leaps in housing aesthetics happened back when the first custom colored MX-style switches began being offered in 2018, and now five years later these massive leaps in design capabilities are surging again. Even things contextually related to switches rotate around and around in cycles. One such switch-related phenomenon which repeats in a (much faster) loop is that of people wanting to make a complete list of “every switch ever”. Almost on a monthly basis for every single month since I started collecting, at least one new...

Nov 1, 2023

Mech Keys

Guides

Drop Updates

storyboardtech

In defense of MT3, the most misunderstood and possibly greatest keycap profile.

Offices are tense spaces, there’s no way around it. Whether they’re silent, museum-like tombs or raucous zoos filled with energy. In this place of distraction, and often discomfort, it’s important to have tools that make you more efficient, comfortable and focused. Personally, I am lucky to work in a happy, healthy work environment with amazing coworkers, but my office is filled with distraction and on my best days it’s a challenging ecosystem in which to create. I’ll be honest, I’m no gamer, and it wasn’t the speedy, silent linear switches or 8000Hz polling rates of gaming boards that drew me to this hobby. It was the spirit of clickety-clackety typewriters of the past and a desire to craft my words on a surface that deserved them… one that amplified my ideas and provided a comfy ambience that encouraged creativity. I don’t feel old, and certainly don’t act old, but I’ve been a designer for 25 of my 43 years and in that whole time I’ve hated the keyboards I’ve used. With the...

Oct 5, 2023

Mech Keys

Guides

Drop Updates

ThereminGoatMK

We Know Nothing About Switch Materials

Figure 1: A fantastic Kailh switch photo from Blitzenx51! There’s any number of different details people look into when they’re trying to pick out switches for their next keyboard build. However, arguably none of them are as vague and mysterious as the materials used to make housings and stems. Yes, even as manufacturers are iffy about their spring weights and newer brands are sketchy about who actually made their switches, differentiating POM from Nylon from Polycarbonate remains to this day the least understood parts of mechanical keyboard switches. For what it’s worth, I don’t have a fix for that either. As someone who has completed a master’s degree in chemical engineering focusing on polymer science, I understand full well that attempting to reverse engineer the formulas of even the most simple keyboard switch materials would take months on end and nearly free-range access to numerous analytical instruments that companies simply won’t hand over to you. However, that...

Sep 27, 2023

Mech Keys

Guides

Drop Updates

Kenshiro70

Getting good backlighting with CSTM and other south-mount keyboards

Drop's had a pretty good history of creating RGB-friendly keyboards. But even with the new south-mount CSTM keyboard line, it is possible to set up a reasonable backlit solution. Level-set Just to get everyone on the same page, "north-mount" LEDs refers to LEDs positioned at the top of the switch socket, which requires mounting the switch with the LED "window" on top and the pins towards the bottom of the keyboard. With certain switches and keycaps, the keycap can contact the top of the switch, resulting in a bad typing feel. "South-mount" switches have the LED on the bottom, allowing the switch the be rotated 180 degrees, with LED window on the bottom and pins on the top. This avoids the contact problem. These days, many switches have a shortened or hollow LED window, sidestepping the contact problem, but there is still a general preference towards south-mount. The Problem Due to its "g4m3r" keyboard history, RGB backlighting has long had a bad rep with serious...

Oct 18, 2023

Mech Keys

Guides