Overall the set is great for fans of LOTR.
On one hand the quality is there: MT3 keycaps are really thick and the dyesub process is quite good and the legends are sharp.
About aesthetics, there is a bit more color contrast between the modifiers and the alpha keys when you finally see the keyset in person, but it is not a bad thing. The red accents are a nice additions but it may end up looking a bit cartoonish. If you want to keep it a bit more discrete, the all-grey configuration works quite nicely.
Grabbed this set on sale. Great quality. Font matches the script of the One Ring. Note that the characters are in Tengwar just like the Elvish set and that the modifier text is the same, so even without the different font it’d still work as a good alternative to the Elvish for less colorful builds.
Good set that completes my full keyboard setup. A little on the expensive side, I do find that these keycaps are prone to scratching which you can see in dimmer light. Very good print clarity. I like the contrasting greys and blacks.
These keycaps are simply gorgeous, the lettering just feels fantastical and elegant. Paired with a black Keychron Q6 Max, it's truly a sinister looking board.