Headphone Modding
more_vert
Hi Everybody. I’m Bill-P. You may know me from Head-Fi or SuperBestAudioFriends (formerly Changstar). I have done a lot of headphone modding in the community and have recently been doing some headphone modding for Massdrop. This led to some questions from Massdrop employees about headphone modding and why I do it. They thought you might like to know how I got into modding headphones and some of my ideas on how to mod. At the end, I’ll also share what I was able to do with the new HiFiMAN HE-350 in making them sound the way that I want them to.
search
Why do I modify headphones?
Basically, I really want to make headphones sound better for everyone and I think that manufacturers should hear how good their headphones can sound if they take more time to tune them. When you buy a high-end model, you expect that the manufacturer has already done all of the engineering for you- from tonality to frequency response to resolution. You assume you’re going to get great design and performance. These days, I typically modify because I want to personalize the sound, which is often what people are looking to do when they buy specific pieces of gear- like a tube amp or a DAC.

What do I want to change?
The start for me actually wasn’t the sound, but the looks that I wanted to change. I thought, “What would happen if I put wood cups on my pair of Audio-Technicas?” (Audio-Technica uses wood cups on their other headphones, like the ATH-W10VTG, and those look good.) Once I began tuning, I realized that using wood cups changes more than the looks; the sound will also change depending on the resonant properties of the cup. That was my “Aha!” moment, my realization that the material used to make the headphones really matters to the sound. I started looking around online and learning what other people were doing with their headphones. I had the ATH-ES10 and found that nobody else had modified them, so I decided to do it myself. The Fostex T50RP had a huge modification thread. That community was so crazy! It was a treasure trove of information on modding headphones, and I took all of my modding cues for my first headphone from there.
What’s the deal with measurement rigs?
I started out using a wand-type omnidirectional microphone (the UMIK-1) to measure the sonic frequencies of my headphones. One of the most effective methods I found early on was to rest the microphone on a pillow or soft surface, and then couple the headphone to that surface. That way, the mic is sandwiched between the headphone and the pillow surface. A good seal helps with bass response, and because that microphone was omnidirectional, it captured the midrange and treble response pretty well too.
search
Later on, I built a dedicated coupler that acts essentially as a headphone stand with the microphone embedded inside (as pictured above). This has allowed me to nail the seal more reliably and to get more consistent bass response than I did with the pillow method. Still, the pillow method is a decent option if you need to quickly check the rough frequency response of a headphone. To that end, I suggest you use your smartphone with a real-time spectrum analyzer app (like Octave RTA on an iPhone) and the Dayton Audio IMM-6 microphone as an inexpensive, quick-and-dirty measurement setup. Download and play a free “Pink Noise” file from www.audiocheck.net and play that file while the microphone captures the headphone response and displays a graph on the app. Take screenshots before and after mods.
search
What’s my approach?
First, I do a “taste test” and listen to the headphone to determine what exactly needs to be done. Then, I try a few things that I know will nudge it back in the right direction and do a few more listening sessions with a number of challenging audio tracks that I know very well. After I’ve achieved a reasonable change in tone, I do some measurements to verify the results.

What are some different techniques?
There are many ways to approach a headphone. The first and most common thing that people do is stuff the back side of the enclosure with some kind of foam material, thereby dampening airflow and reflections. This will hopefully tighten up the lower frequencies. Swapping out the ear pads can also change the response in a very positive way, and I would argue that may actually be the most important change you can make to a headphone. The pads can absorb certain frequencies or change the distance of the driver to your ear, which can change how certain frequencies interact with the enclosed space. More advanced techniques involve putting things in front of the driver in order to obstruct and reduce higher frequencies and normalize the response of the driver. Other advanced techniques involve “mass loading” (in the case of mods with materials like Dynamat and Blu-Tack); treating the diaphragm of the driver (that’s what I suspect LFF does to his headphones); and what I’ve started dabbling with recently: using metal foil tape to improve the rigidity of the enclosure and intentionally induce reflections (I think that’s what is happening).
search

search
What are some materials you can use?
There are a lot of different materials involved in a mod. I think acoustic foam and various kinds of open-cell foam are the most popular types, but there are others with specific purposes—like Dynamat and Blu-Tack, which can be used to increase the mass of an enclosure and potentially change the resonance characteristics of the enclosure itself. Felt can be used to dampen reflections and reduce high frequencies when it’s placed in front of the driver. For a more dramatic effect, some modders will use toilet paper in place of felt. :) Closed-cell foam can be used very effectively to dampen even more reflection, as was done in the Anaxilus mod of the Sennheiser HD800. Rug liners typically have the same properties as closed-cell foam, with the added benefit of being more open.
search
What was my process for modifying the HE-350?
From listening, I know that this headphone runs into some trouble in the high frequencies, so the first thing I did was look to see what HiFiMAN had done to the front side of the driver. When I opened up the enclosure, I found a single layer of felt covering the driver. That, combined with the filter cloth of the ear pads, should have reduced the high frequencies—but it didn’t seem to be enough. I thought I would replace the felt layer with more layers of toilet paper (taking cues from Marvey) and other kinds of paper (like a medical face-mask filter or some tissue), since these are better at damping high frequencies. Then, I thought I could swap out the ear pads, since more distance from the ear to the driver and help get back some of the sense of “air” that the papers would get rid of. Just those very simple changes were enough to nudge the response of the HE-350 to something I would consider a really good improvement. The modification didn’t take that long to finish, and actually, the most difficult part was fitting the ear pads back on! The changes I was able to make are a sign to me that this is a good platform for modifying. I get a great sense of satisfaction that I want to share when I make headphones sound better.
search

search

search

The Results: Before (Blue Line) & After (Red Line)
search

Any Questions?
I will be travelling a bit during the summer and may have some issues with my internet connection, but feel free to ask me some questions or to discuss headphone modding. I’ll be happy to help when I can.
Also, you can read more about frequency response graphs here: https://www.massdrop.com/article/understanding-headphone-reviews
And the Massdrop x HiFiMAN HE-350 is here: https://www.massdrop.com/buy/massdrop-x-hifiman-he-350
thumb_upNYCrucial, fmulderme, and 44 others
46
43
remove_red_eye
19.6K
bookmark_border
Bill-P
65

search
Monkdoctor
6
Jun 12, 2020
bookmark_border
I gave the stock drivers and ear pad to my 15 year old. This is what he came up with.
search
search
search
search

Jun 12, 2020
Monkdoctor
6
May 5, 2020
bookmark_border
Nice write up. I had time to blow off steam from this COVID lockdown in Cali. I modded my HE-35X. Didn't bother listening to them stock. Gutted it out and put in some electrostatic drivers. See the stock driver in the background.
search
search

May 5, 2020
Monkdoctor
6
Jun 2, 2020
bookmark_border
Click on the Torac Audio link. That is a fantastic looking driver. What is the diameter of the driver? Did you have to make some sort of adapter to fit them into the headphone cups? I owned an Ananda and then trade them in for a the Ananda BT. Fantastic sounding BT planar by the way. Looks ridiculous when you wear them, but it's all about the sound quality. My drivers came out a pair of pollinator which I shattered on hardwood flooring. Rather then send them back to get fixed, it motivated me to learn Fusion 360 CAD software and 3D printing. Got to love how easy the latest consumer filament 3D printers are now to set up and use. My mod stats have good low end impact similar to planar, very detailed mids and highs without the sizzle you often hear in planar drivers. They sound most similar to my HD700 but faster and more detailed. Nectar Sound does not sell the drivers individually as you can imagine the liability of amateur tinkerer strapping on electrostatic drivers which have their stators energized with +- 400 to 500 volts and the diaphragm energized with 600+ volts. Homemade electric chairs would not look good on one's resume. I think the planar magnetic drivers are a lot safer to play around with.
Jun 2, 2020
MWildebeast
13
Jun 2, 2020
bookmark_border
I'm honestly impressed with the level of quality that Matthew of Torac Audio was able to achieve. According to his product page, the diameter is 88mm. I designed and 3D printed a couple of plates, one that goes on the backside of the driver which secures it to the cups, and another that goes on the front side that the pads attach to. Glad to hear you were able to salvage the drivers! It would honestly be kind of cool if you could purchase just the drivers, but liability would certainly be a concern with those kinds of voltages. I can't imagine how much work it would be to write up a thorough enough release of liability form to purchase them for DIY use. I'll definitely have to look into Nectar Sound once the funds present themselves.
Jun 2, 2020
HY_MAAH
0
Oct 4, 2019
bookmark_border
dhuul miya ..//?
Oct 4, 2019
ambush_boy
0
Aug 2, 2019
bookmark_border
This was very enjoyable to read for me, I like how simple and detailed you made this to understand, to me it always seems with such a small surface area the most minor changes can make a difference .
Aug 2, 2019
SkyCyclePilot
18
Aug 28, 2018
bookmark_border
Would love to find an easy mod that would make up for the lousy bass punch and thunder on the HifiMan HE400i. Any ideas???
Aug 28, 2018
Selfish_Android
142
May 29, 2017
bookmark_border
Usually mods are made for bass improvement and treble dampening, that's exactly the opposite i want from headphones. Anyway i have the HE400i and i removed the cloth behind the grill and i'm looking to replace the earpads with Ori earpads, do anyone know any other mod that may improve soundstage and treble?
May 29, 2017
Mp4rp0za
2
Jun 20, 2018
bookmark_border
you can add a little extra boost in the treble with replacing your earcups with a smaller (in distance) ones 'cause with this trick you have the driver less far from your ear and the muddy trelbe come alive :)
Jun 20, 2018
GUTB
232
Oct 2, 2016
bookmark_border
People should be highly suspicious of headphone modding. It often appears to be a string of mods that attempts to fix the problems the last mod introduced until the result is something similar to stock that the modder pretends is an improvement.
Oct 2, 2016
Z3phyrOverEar
15
Oct 3, 2016
bookmark_border
I think most modders disagree; improving headphones is beneficial if you are careful.
Oct 3, 2016
jxliu
951
Engineer
Oct 1, 2016
bookmark_border
(posting the link here to make it easier to find) Easy bass boost mod posted by Will: https://www.massdrop.com/buy/massdrop-x-hifiman-he-350/talk/530648
Oct 1, 2016
Z3phyrOverEar
15
Sep 28, 2016
bookmark_border
Is there any chance you could do a "wood mod" for he-350s or the m40x?
Sep 28, 2016
Schmexy
92
Oct 1, 2016
bookmark_border
The internet.. The best place to learn new things..
Oct 1, 2016
Z3phyrOverEar
15
Oct 1, 2016
bookmark_border
That's why I use it :)
Oct 1, 2016
PSquare
17
Jul 8, 2016
bookmark_border
"I'm just a caveman. I fell on some ice and later got thawed out by some of your scientists. Your world frightens and confuses me", but I would wait until you get your headphones and they have broken-in before you modify them.
Jul 8, 2016
felipeRC
0
Jan 25, 2018
bookmark_border
sometimes I just want to get out of my BMW and run to the hills or whatever.
Jan 25, 2018
Showing 22 of 43
keyboard_arrow_up
Newest
43 OF 43 POSTS
Jul 7, 2020
keyboard_arrow_down
Oldest