The look of it is great, no issues there. I do wish the plaque on the front either didn't exist or said Barad-Dur instead.
ISSUES:
It does not sit flat. This is caused by the On/Off switch and battery lid tab on the bottom protruding farther than the velvet. This can easily be fixed by having a smaller switch / lid tab or by adding a thicker velvet bottom.
The keycap gets stuck when pressed. If the Eye is facing you, you press the key and have to pull it out to reset it. If the Eye is facing the left or right it works as I imagine it normally should. I am unsure if this is an issue with the housing at the top being too tight or a faulty switch.
LeeYuhmAppreciate the feedback and review points. There was an email sent recently, along with a comment in the discussion section, that details some fixes that are in the works for this keycap holder (resolving both of the issues you mention here). I hope that the replacement unit lives up to the expectations and arrives without issue. Please do let us know your thoughts after receiving it.