Yeah I don't really think claiming $2,500 MSRP is fair. Before production stopped (2010) I know used ones were going for $600-$700 each depending on condition. New weren't that much more ($800? $900?) as they were known to last forever if you treated them well.
After production the price has continued to rise as the supply of new-in-box decks dwindles, but that doesn't mean you can claim any MSRP you want.